New York's Cooperative and Condominium Community

Habitat Magazine Insider Guide




A Bronx Co-op Overcomes Its Troubled Past

Ron Egatz in Bricks & Bucks

The Bronx

Wallace Avenue

The Wallace Avenue co-op in the Bronx that survived a death sentence (photo by Jennifer Wu)

A few years ago, a 190-unit co-op on Wallace Avenue in the Bronx was on the brink of financial ruin. After an officer at Marine Midland Bank called to say the sponsor was not paying the mortgage, sharp-elbowed negotiations won an extension of the mortgage – and a promise from the sponsor to auction off his 96 apartments and turn any unsold units over to the co-op. The sponsor gave up his role as property manager and his seats on the board, and he made a $300,000 contribution to the reserve fund. A new management company was brought in and a board election was held. It appeared a new day had dawned.

But appearances can be deceiving. The next call from the bank was more bad news: many of the former sponsor-owned apartments had gone into arrears. The bank had decided to sell the building to an investor who planned to dissolve the co-op and turn the property into a rental. A new investor came in to forestall that death sentence, but the board sued this new sponsor and eventually won control of his units. Saved from the grave, the co-op board has since addressed some 500 building code violations and undertaken a long laundry list of capital improvements, including:

• One elevator out of four has been completely replaced, with the other three to be completed by the summer of 2017.

• A new security system.

• New common area lighting.

• A new natural-gas boiler.

• Facade repairs and improvements.

In hindsight, it’s apparent that this co-op’s troubles began when the board and shareholders ignored three very bright red flags: (1) the sponsor doubled as managing agent; (2) the sponsor held roughly half of the shares in the corporation; and (3) the sponsor controlled the board of directors.

The co-op shareholders might also have turned to the state Attorney General's office for relief, says Arthur Weinstein, a real estate attorney not connected with the Bronx co-op – if it could be shown that the sponsor was ignoring his obligations to relinquish control of the board and sell off his units, as prescribed in the offering plan.

Ask the Experts

learn more

Learn all the basics of NYC co-op and condo management, with straight talk from heavy hitters in the field of co-op or condo apartments

Professionals in some of the key fields of co-op and condo board governance and building management answer common questions in their areas of expertise

Source Guide

see the guide

Looking for a vendor?