HABITAT

BOARD OPERATIONS

The Marriott Model: How a Middle-Class Co-op Put a Million in the Bank

Stephen Vernon in Board Operations on September 27, 2012

NaBors Apartments, Inwood, Manhattan

Entrance, 14 Bogardus Place, Manhattan

14 Bogardus Place

 
Sept. 27, 2012

NaBors Apartments, my three-building, 111-unit cooperative at 31-37 Nagle Avenue (right) and 14 Bogardus Place in Inwood, faces the same problems as other buildings: how to get through the year while remaining fiscally sound. I had some experience dealing with money matters before I joined the co-op's finance committee: I had worked in hotel accounting, followed by a stint doing accounting at a large insurance company. Eventually, I was elected to the co-op board, serving as assistant treasurer, then treasurer and now as president of what is formally called Nagle Apartments Corp.

My building is not wealthy. But we were able to take small steps to improve our finances, and your co-op or condo can, too.

  • We began to raise our maintenance each year by a small amount in line with inflation. We started a permanent assessment of 2.5 percent of maintenance, and our goal is to raise that to 10 percent within four years (partially in response to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac requirements).
  • We established a self-escrow for our property taxes so we can earn interest ahead of time while saving up the cash and then take advantage of the pay-early savings for the second through fourth quarter charges. (Our bank, NCB, agreed to drop the bank escrow.)
  • We also established water/sewer and insurance self-escrows that we could pay off immediately and not incur insurance premium finance charges or line-of-credit charges. These are also a great source of emergency working capital.

By the time 2011 had been audited, we had current assets and reserves of over $1 million, over $1 million of positive stockholders' equity, and a positive cash flow. Our book value is nearing $100 per share (an average two-bedroom unit has 135 shares).

And Now, a Word about our Sponsor

That said, I have to admit that it's not all because of superior fiscal planning. When the sponsor went bankrupt, the co-op took over 15 rental units. When a renter leaves, we renovate and sell the vacated unit. We currently have six left. With the money from the nine sold so far, we have replaced all windows and A/C units, repaired the building roofs, and raised reserves and self-escrows without assessments to our shareholders.

But it is one thing to take advantage of a special deal: it is another to transition to sustainable finances. Our supply of units is running out and the remaining occupants appear to be there for the long haul.

While the co-op has made excellent progress, I do not consider us out of the woods yet. Our maintenance charges need to cover our depreciation expense in addition to the (already covered) debt service. Covering the depreciation is so very important but often overlooked. Depreciation expense represents costs associated with the wearing out of the original building, previous capital repairs, and improvements. For most of these, future repairs and replacements will have to be made.

Y'know What's the Trouble with Depreciation?

The trouble with depreciation is that it represents the historical cost, not the replacement cost. Therefore, if an organization is not taking in sufficient funds to replace items at historical cost, there is little hope the organization will have the funds to cover the replacement cost without borrowing or assessment.

I encourage all boards to undertake their financial planning from the perspective of what is sustainable not just for the upcoming year but for the long haul. Ask yourselves: at which amount of maintenance will the co-op not only meet its short-term operating costs but also its long-term goals?

Co-op and condo boards all need to move away from the operating model of keeping maintenance low when this level does not meet the sustainable needs of the corporation to a model of what is sustainable for the long term. That will not only save the shareholders along the way, but make the board's job easier as well.

 

For more, see our Site Map or join our Archive >>

Ask the Experts

learn more

Learn all the basics of NYC co-op and condo management, with straight talk from heavy hitters in the field of co-op or condo apartments

Professionals in some of the key fields of co-op and condo board governance and building management answer common questions in their areas of expertise

Source Guide

see the guide

Looking for a vendor?