New York's Cooperative and Condominium Community

Habitat Magazine Business of Management 2021

HABITAT

BOARD OPERATIONS

HOW CO-OP/CONDO BOARDS OPERATE

Condo Apartment in Foreclosure Limbo. Get the Unhelpful Bank on Your Side.

David J. Byrne in Board Operations on November 25, 2011

New York City

Nov. 25, 2011

It doesn't have to remain empty, an albatross around your neck. During a pending bank foreclosure, New York law provides for the appointment of a rent receiver. The rent receiver is empowered to take possession of the empty unit and rent it in turn, with portions of the rent used to pay ongoing, current common charges and any common-charge arrears.

Instead of wasting time seeking a money judgment against an owner that had long since fled, we worked with the board to enter an appearance in the bank's foreclosure (which should have been done from the outset and should almost always be done) and thereafter filed papers seeking the court's creation of a receivership.

The bank and its attorneys, in this instance, followed the general litigation-lawyer rule: "If my adversary lawyer is in favor of something, I must oppose it." Unfortunately, attorneys working with banks to process those banks' foreclosures typically work according to some set program and historical approach, and are thereby unable to understand and/or appreciate anything that seems foreign and/or that is not on their bank foreclosure attorney "cheat sheet."

Upon the bank's opposition to our client's application, we contacted bank counsel. We explained the non-monetary benefits that could accrue to a bank while the condominium containing its unit maintains and carries out a rent receivership.

  • We explained how a unit occupied by a responsible tenant, subject to a written and proper lease, would be far more likely to be habitable and marketable once that bank finally got around to completing its foreclosure.
  • We discussed the condition in which many banks find units after those units have sat empty during the long, drawn out, excruciatingly slow foreclosure process (i.e., mold, water damage, unusable appliances).

Once the bank's lawyer understood that our client's position was supported by both New York law and the "real world" facts connected with empty condominium units waiting for foreclosures to end, he agreed that it was best to negotiate a resolution to the pending court-filed receivership application.

The parties discussed an agreement by which a receiver would find, install and maintain a tenant, with the receiver obligated to maintain the unit during the tenancy and to share data/documentation with the bank. The condominium expects to generate significant funds during this receivership.

COMMENT This illustrates the strategies and approaches that condominiums can employ when faced with abandoned units and suffering through incredibly slow bank foreclosures. Far from a curse, such a situation can be an opportunity if handled with care, thoughtfulness, and aggression.

Many condominium boards and their attorneys fall into the same bad habits into which bank foreclosure lawyers have fallen — that is, approaching delinquent owners and/or past-due common charges with a lack of creativity, passion or thoughtfulness, instead relying on a "script" prepared long ago, during a vastly different time and related to a vastly different real estate situation and economy.

When faced with a delinquent unit, boards and their attorneys should develop a creative strategy based on the actual facts of a particular delinquent unit, and not on what their "script" says. Those boards, and the condominium residents they serve, will enjoy a far greater measure of success than they have had.

 

David J. Byrne  is an attorney at Stark & Stark

From the November 2011 issue of Habitat magazine. For print-magazine articles back to 2002, join our Archive >>

Ask the Experts

learn more

Learn all the basics of NYC co-op and condo management, with straight talk from heavy hitters in the field of co-op or condo apartments

Professionals in some of the key fields of co-op and condo board governance and building management answer common questions in their areas of expertise

Source Guide

see the guide

Looking for a vendor?