Board Service: Angela Hirsch, Queens
By Angela Hirsch. Third in an occasional series of real-life stories by board members about serving on co-op and condo boards.
June 11, 2008 — What an incredible learning experience…! As the long-time president of my cooperative's board of directors, hardly a week goes by when I am not faced with another issue, or find myself researching or communicating with those involved in our building's daily activities. I jokingly say to the newbies on the board: "Behind every door is another story."
And for me, it all started over 20 years ago with a loose window.
Share Article 
Share Article 
Tip a Friend
Print Article
My husband and I had moved into the Saxony, a 100-unit co-op in Forest Hills, about 30 years ago. At some point, our windows kept sliding down, and the only way I could keep one open was to prop it up with a bamboo stick. This was, to say the least, frustrating. And although rumors of new windows had been heard for years, nothing seemed to be on the horizon.
I needed to find out what "they" were really planning, so I attended my first board meeting. Before I knew it, I had volunteered to serve on the board — a pretty new group at that time since our building had only recently been converted to co-op.
New windows did come, and they turned out to be only the beginning of our improvements. I am now at ease discussing boilers, roofs, landscaping, storage facilities, elevator upgrades, fuel and electricity conservation, the whys and wherefores of house rules, proprietary leases, bylaws, and legal this and legal that. My chief regret is that continuing education credits aren't awarded for serving as a board member — I could have earned an MBA by now! Why, I even study the building code and New York Law Journal — and www.nyc.gov is one of my regular stops on the Internet.
My commitment is definitely a passion rather than a pastime. It's been a long — at times stressful, but mostly fulfilling — series of challenges. I've made a lot of friends, and sometimes enemies, along the way. I am proud of our innovations and accomplishments, and relish the feeling of satisfaction when a neighbor compliments me on my endeavors and ideas — yes, not everyone complains!
My biggest disappointment was not being able to convince the majority of our shareholders to agree to a bylaw change allowing a flip tax. In the scheme of things it could be a lot worse, since our co-op is in excellent financial shape; our assessment will just have to stay in place until we reach that magic "comfortable number" our accountant keeps telling us about.
A close second, however, might well have been when I was told by the then-board members that I was off my rocker for suggesting that the garage tenants should paint their allotted space, and that we provide the paint! The garage still hasn't been painted.
The Ultimate House Rule
What lessons can I give from all this? First and foremost, you must be willing to be a "doer" and not just a "talker." If you want something done, do it yourself, but remember the Golden Rule.
Now, however, I'm really thinking it might be time to give up my role. I've been contemplating this for a while, talked about it with my long-suffering husband and even plucked up the courage to tell the rest of our board and our managing agent. "The choice is yours," they say, "but we'd like you to stay." Most everything has been taken care of for now, except I've got to keep pushing for new tree pits … and our sidewalks need fixing … there's that water leak under the terrazzo tiles in the lobby … and of course, we're embarking on our next Local Law 11 façade project.
Oy, the guilt!
Yesterday, as I always do at this time of year, I started writing the outline for the annual shareholders-meeting speech. We've long since changed our bylaws to allow for a staggered board, and this year my position is up for election. I got to the part where I say, "And this year there are two slots to be filled. We have a volunteer to run again and…" But after a few minutes of pondering, I couldn't bring myself to say anything about my slot. So, what do I do?
I've still got another few weeks to agonize before the proxies go out. Should I stay for just one more year?
Adapted from Habitat June 2008. For the complete article and more, join our Archive >>
Comments
Log in or create a user account to comment.
Learn from your peers by posing questions in the Habitat Board Talk Forums.
Apropos of CIRA, may I suggest some simple rules?
1. President does not sign checks, e.g. not authorized.
2. President does not... more
CIRA booklet
I, and many of our board members, tend to agree with...more
Posted by: Manhattan President, 32 units
09/06/2008 01:21 pm
We embarked on a project to replace all the old corroded plumbing risers. NYC regulations require abatement of asbestos if more than a certain amount Read More »
Posted by: Brooklyn President, 75 units
09/04/2008 12:32 pm
It gives me great pleasure to use this forum within which to share my experience as Board President of a 75 unit Brooklyn-based converted co-op. I hope Read More »
Learn all the basics of being a board-member, straight from our baker's-dozen movers and shakers.
2008 Source Guide
Be sure to check out our 2008 Source Guide – chock-full of great resources for your board. It is available online, and you can also get your organization listed as a provider.
September 2008
Building champions, lobby renovations, and our 12th annual attorney survey! See this month's contents >>
Your Go-To Place! Use Our Annual Directory of Suppliers, Vendors, Property Managers, Real-Estate Professionals and More to Find Everything You Need! Go for it »






Add comment